Score: 9

"Good times"

submission: Clay Collections 2

date: February 22, 2005

My only beef is that I wish you had used the Take Two version of my song, it sounds a lot cleaner. But it fit nicely, this is one of the better animations I have seen that used this tune.

Score: 4

"Could've been WAY better..."

submission: Simpsons Home Inter. V2

date: February 6, 2005

I thought you did a nice job capturing the layout and look of the house, but beyond that it was just boring. It looked like you used up all your ideas for interactive objects on the first floor, as I couldn't find many on the 2nd floor, and absolutely none in Maggie's room. The soundboard was okay, but I would've liked it better if you had placed sounds around the house to go with the interactive objects. And some background music would really liven this up.

Score: 10

"It rocked"

submission: Catfight

date: January 31, 2005

Shame on the rest of you for judging this in relation to every other fighting flash. Clearly Madelief was trying to do something different here, but all of you seem to want more of those hackneyed and overdone stick/DBZ ripoff fights. A risk was taken, and apparently was underappreciated. I for one commend Madelief on this approach, and I hope the rest of you will save your shut minds for next week's cross burning.

Score: 4

"Way sloppy, man"

submission: Basshands

date: February 17, 2005

This was cool, but your playing was just messy. If you're going to be the bass player, you have to be the rock too. The whole band's going to collapse if you meander around the beat like this, even during an improvisation.

Score: 4

"It was original, diverse, and had lots of effort"

submission: Reaper of Apocalypse

date: February 6, 2005

But I have to agree with Redbull to some extent. It's clear that you know how to handle a guitar, but it sounds like you're trying to show off all your techniques in one song, and that never works. I'd rather hear a song comprised of 2 or 3 amazing riffs instead of 12 average ones (that's why I don't listen to psycho death metal). You definitely have the skills to make a really great metal track, just remember that one song will not impress everybody.

Score: 8

"Just this side of bitchin'"

submission: Metal-o-Mania

date: February 1, 2005

Reminds me a lot of Pantera, but more importantly, drop some drums under this and it'll fucking blow people away. I don't care if they're programmed, some percussion would take this to the next level. I especially loved the little shred line, keep this up!